FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Thursday, October 6, 2016
Contact: Arn Pearson, arn@prwatch.org
Center for Media and Democracy and Common Cause file extensive new evidence in whistleblower tax fraud case against ALEC
ExxonMobil and the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) are running an illegal scheme to promote the oil giant’s climate denial policies and legislative agenda in violation of U.S. tax law governing charitable organizations, the Center for Media Democracy (CMD) and Common Cause charged today.
In a new filing to the IRS – adding to an active investigation prompted by a 2012 complaint that ALEC is operating as a corporate lobbying group while registered as a 501(c)(3) nonprofit charity – the watchdog organizations detail for the first time how Exxon has used ALEC as a key asset in its explicit campaign to sow uncertainty about climate science, undermine international climate treaties and block legislation to reduce emissions. While ALEC purports to spend zero dollars on lobbying, Exxon has deliberately used ALEC for the past two decades to advance its legislative goals concerning cap-and-trade policies, fracking, the Keystone Pipeline and the Obama Administration’s Clean Power Plan.
“It has become painfully obvious over the past few years that ALEC is corporate lobby front group masquerading as a charity—at taxpayer expense,” said Arn Pearson, general counsel at CMD. “If the laws governing nonprofits are to mean anything, the IRS needs to take action to enforce them in this case.”
“For years ALEC has been a key asset in Exxon’s multi-billion dollar campaign to push a dangerous climate-denial agenda and secretly lobby politicians on anti-environmental legislation that pollutes the environment,” said Karen Hobert Flynn, president of Common Cause. “It is time for the IRS to act and curb these blatant abuses.”
Today, CMD and Common Cause provided the IRS Whistleblower Office with extensive evidence obtained through open records requests, original research and public financial documents detailing intentional misuse of ALEC by the Exxon to advance legislation of direct benefit to the company. Over a 17-year period, Exxon and its foundation spent more than $1.7 million to finance lobbying activity by ALEC on legislation and public policies that benefit the corporation, while improperly and illegally claiming a tax deduction for those expenditures.
“ALEC acts as a nonprofit lobbying concierge, with Exxon its eager patron,” said Eric Havian, a partner at Constantine Cannon and a prominent whistleblower lawyer handling the case. “It is corrupt to use the tax laws as a cover for corporate lobbying, but it’s even worse in this case. Exxon uses ALEC’s charitable status to fuel its disinformation campaign on climate change, so taxpayers are literally paying Exxon to lie to them.”
Exxon has paid substantial sums to serve in a leadership capacity at ALEC, both on the group’s corporate board and on energy-related issue task forces, where corporations introduce “model” legislation and hold de facto veto power over what bills are subsequently promoted by ALEC. Exxon’s collusion with ALEC has helped introduce scores of coordinated bills in state houses across the country, including resolutions in 22 states to oppose EPA’s plan to regulate greenhouse gases.
That activity constitutes a gross violation of federal tax laws by Exxon in its own right, and further reinforces the case against ALEC for abuse of its 501(c)(3) charitable status.
In a letter to IRS Commissioner John Koskinen, CMD and Common Cause urged the agency to expedite the Whistleblower Office’s open and active investigation into potential civil and criminal liability for both ALEC and Exxon, revoke ALEC’s 501(c)(3) status, impose any necessary civil and criminal penalties, and collect unpaid back and present taxes for nondeductible lobbying activities from both ALEC and its corporate donors.
Last month, CMD released notes from closed-door meetings between Republican attorneys general and fossil fuel industry lobbyists to coordinate on defending ExxonMobil as the company faces an ongoing investigation over allegations that it intentionally misled the public and its own shareholders about climate change.
The concept of a “bill mill” should be patently illegal. The question becomes will the existing legal entities, in this case the IRS, do anything about it or will there just be a shrug of the shoulders & a “that’s just the way things are” dismissal of this corporate assault on American citizen rights.
why isn’t the IRS taking action???
I’ve always wondered why the Dems don’t start their version of ALEC.
ALEC has violated their status as a “non-profit”. We know there are lots of so-called non-profits that are fronts for various causes that primarily benefit the founders of the non-profit and ALEC is no exception. They were primarily funded by the Koch Brothers to do their bidding in creating the USA in their own image. They have brain washed Congress with their “secret” meetings that they know the general populace would violently disagree with. These meetings are un-American and violates our Constitution. Why the IRS has not eliminated them from non-profit status is unbelievable, unless of course the IRS is also a beneficiary of the money of the Koch Brothers. who have so many secretive deals that where it comes from is hard to find. Our Governor Scott made a special deal with the Koch Brothers where they are dumping millions of gallons of toxic waste into a Florida river with Scott’s blessing, but not the blessings of the citizenry of Florida. We need to not allow our politicians to destroy our country for their personal benefit. I know Scott wants the support of the Koch’s for his eventual bid to run for President…..heaven help us, which would be worse than even Trump or Hillary. Here again it’s not what the public wants, it’s what is pushed through by the party machinery, just as Obama and Biden endorsed Patrick Murphy instead of a better candidate Alan Grayson!